Savings Club for Savings Tips
NBCI Roundtable Summary
June 23, 2008
To address the foreclosure crisis in Wayne County, the National Black Church
Initiative (NBCI), Fannie Mae, and Wayne County convened a meeting of stakeholders
on June 23, 2008 at Christ Church in Detroit. The purpose of the meeting was
to educate stakeholders on current solutions to address the crisis, identify
needs, and create a plan to address gaps in existing solutions. The meeting was a follow up to a May 15 roundtable with Wayne County and the NBCI.
Wayne County Michigan and Detroit continue to be hard hit by the national
foreclosure crisis. These statistics were shared by Jamele Hage, who is leading
the Wayne County, MI efforts on foreclosure prevention:
- In 2007, there were over 27,000 foreclosures in Wayne County,
a 90% increase from 2006.
- In 2008, the number of foreclosures in Wayne County is expected
to top 50,000.
Reverend Anthony Evans President, National Black Church Initiative (NBCI)
Reverend Carole Cole Flanagan Rector, Christ Church of Detroit
Mary Lee Widener, NHSA
Ernest Baskette, NHSA
Shelia Green, Fannie Mae
David Elam, Fannie Mae
Charmaine Brown, Fannie Mae
Ray Leech, Fannie Mae
Jamele Hage, Wayne County MI MFPP
Terrence Keit, Chief Deputy Treasurer, Wayne County MI
Robert Clouston, Office of Congresswoman Jeanne Kilpatrick
Melody L. Light, Esq., Office of Congressman John Conyers
Mike Fontana, Michigan MBA
Bill Sullivan, United Way 211
Reverend Gloria Smith Vincent, Mission of Peace
Latesha Slappy, Mission of Peace
Judith Robinson, Lighthouse Community Development
Tony Le Wars, Neighborworks America
Nancy Walker, Chase
Patty Scully, GMAC
Carita Bowers, GMAC
Rebecca Ketchum, Wells Fargo
Michael Hillebrand, Trott and Trott (Attorney firm)
Jeff Anderson, Wayne County Community College
Turkia Mullin, Wayne County Land Bank
Highlights of Roundtable Discussion
- On Monday, June 23, the team kicked off the roundtable of key stakeholders
at the Christ Church in Detroit. The event was attended by key stakeholders
and began with each participant identifying one issue of critical concern,
and their desired outcome for the meeting. Reverend Anthony Evans of NBCI facilitated
the discussion, and presentations were delivered by Shelia Green,
Reverend Vincent of Mission of Peace, Jamele Hage, and Mary Lee Widener of
- Mary Lee discussed NHSA’s patient capital fund, R Home, and gave an overview of JPS Platform solutions. Wayne County officials were very interested in these efforts and offered NHSA (at the suggestion of Congresswoman Kilpatrick’s representative) office space to get the programs off the ground in Detroit.
- Detroit Hope discussed its June 25th outreach event and the fact
that servicers are concerned that things in the surrounding areas were so devastating
that in many cases, people cannot afford the gas to attend their seminars.
It was noted that there should be a focus on a "dignified exit" when
all options have been exhausted for people to remain in their homes.
- The Servicers reported that borrower contact remains a big issue.
It was suggested, rather strongly, that the industry begin to partner with
nonprofits to reach out to their "no contacts" by providing a list to
these organizations. The privacy issue was raised, and options to address explored as a next
- Participants also wanted to explore holding a Phone-A-Thon as they
heard reports that this was an effective way to reach homeowners following
the Cincinnati event.
- Terrence Keit, the Chief Deputy Treasurer of Wayne County highlighted
the department's "Operation Normandy" effort that has
aligned his office with over 20 local nonprofit agencies on outreach to impacted communities on
a wide range of social service issues.
- Congresswoman Kilpatrick's office discussed how the use of
trusted advisors in the community was critical and how it was important to educate young
people about the process and responsibilities of purchasing and owning a
- The MBA and Wayne County expressed a desire for the industry to focus on consistent messages to homeowners and access to web-based information on solutions for borrowers having difficulty paying their mortgages. The MBA in Michigan is developing a borrower resource guide to help address this issue, and Wayne County is offering borrower seminars on the web. Both organizations expressed concerns that when borrower conduits, such as family, friends, trusted advisors and others, provide mis-information, it becomes widespread and exacerbates the problem.
Detroit Hope servicers will be actively engaged going forward. Nancy
Walter from Chase agreed to work with Fannie Mae to set up future calls. Additional
action items include:
- Jamele Hage will utilize her Advisory Council to involve the
participants of the roundtable on an ongoing basis and the group
agreed that the MFPP plan to host outreach events and provide
borrower counseling via their web site would be a key to success.
- Fannie Mae will provide information on their "lease to own"
pilot and also will look for assistance in identifying possible
- United Way 211 committed to exploring revising it scripts to
determine whether individuals who seek their services are also
homeowners. UM 211 believe it can steer homeowners in trouble
- Rebecca Ketchum of Wells Fargo has proposed a "faith-based"
strategy to increase borrower contact.
- Fannie Mae is working with the Wayne County MFPP on their outreach
events, the web site and will participate in their Advisory Council.
One focus will be seeing if additional counseling staff can be
trained for this effort. Fannie Mae could also utilize direct
mail to impacted borrowers as part of the outreach event planning.
- Mike Shea of ACORN will follow up with Wayne County to begin
plans to open an office in Detroit.
- The NHSA is piloting their "Patient Capital Fund" approach in
Detroit and will work with Rev Evans on developing a "mechanism"
to offer this model more widely, perhaps through his network of
- Jamele offered Mary Lee Widener of NHSA the use of the Wayne
County office to support an NHSA presence in Detroit.
- Reverend Evans will explore faith-based institutions bringing
buses of congregants and parishioners to Hope Now foreclosure
Kick off of the Event by a Christ Church Parishioner along with Reverend Carole Cole Flanagan of Christ Church and Rev Anthony Evans.
Rev Evans and Reverend Flanagan of Christ Church.
Charmaine Brown and Shelia Green from Fannie Mae were the “co-hosts” of the event and led many
of the discussions.
Roundtable participants including (from left) Rebecca Ketchum from Wells Fargo, Mary Lee
Widener and Ernest Baskette of NHSA and Bill Sullivan from United Way 211.